Jonelle Matthews came home from a Christmas concert. Then she vanished

SOLVEDNear Greeley, Colorado0:3221 October 2026

After her school Christmas concert in December 1984, a friend's dad drove her home in Greeley, Colorado, where she was home alone that night. Almost thirty-five years later, pipeline workers found her remains. In 2022 a former youth pastor at her family's church was convicted of her kidnapping and murder. Send this to someone from Greeley. Narrated with an AI voice. Every fact is sourced on Casepin.

Narrated from the published, cited case file. The sources are on the case page. How we make these videos.