Start here
The Mad Butcher, Cleveland Torso Killer - Still Unsolved ?? Mystery and Makeup | Bailey Sarian
Bailey Sarian's 38-minute breakdown, the fullest single telling on file.
Watch on YouTubeWhat happened
Overview
Between 1935 and 1938, an unidentified perpetrator killed and dismembered at least twelve people whose remains were left in and around Kingsbury Run, an impoverished area of Cleveland, Ohio, known locally as "The Roaring Third" or "Hobo Jungle." Most victims were drifters, transient laborers, or "working poor" people living in nearby shantytowns during the Great Depression; only three of the twelve official victims were ever positively identified. Some researchers believe the true number of victims could be higher, potentially including a woman known as the "Lady of the Lake" (found 1934) and Robert Robertson (found 1950), as well as additional unsolved dismemberment cases near Pittsburgh and New Castle, Pennsylvania.
Pattern of the Killings
Victims were typically decapitated, and many were further dismembered, with male victims often castrated. Some remains showed evidence of chemical treatment that altered the skin's texture and color. Bodies were frequently found long after death, sometimes over a year later, which along with the limited forensic science of the era made identification difficult. Identified victims included Edward Andrassy and Florence Polillo, confirmed through fingerprints, and a tentative identification of Rose Wallace via dental records.
Investigation
Eliot Ness, then Cleveland's Public Safety Director, became involved in the investigation and privately questioned a leading suspect, a local physician, who reportedly failed two polygraph examinations administered by Leonarde Keeler. Ness ultimately did not pursue prosecution, in part due to the suspect's family connection to a political rival. The suspect later committed himself to an institution and allegedly sent Ness threatening postcards for years afterward. A second suspect, Frank Dolezal, was arrested in connection with Polillo's death; he initially confessed, then retracted the confession, alleging it was coerced. Dolezal died by hanging in custody at the Cuyahoga County jail, a death officially ruled a suicide; he was later posthumously exonerated regarding the Torso killings. Detective Peter Merylo led a separate line of inquiry, including going undercover, and considered links to similar dismemberment killings found near Pittsburgh and New Castle, Pennsylvania.
Investigators also considered Willie Johnson, who was tried and convicted for a separate 1942 killing with alleged links to two identified Torso victims, though he was never conclusively tied to the Torso murders; he was executed in 1944.
Status
The case remains officially unsolved. Approximately 9,100 people were interviewed during the original investigation. In 2024, the Cuyahoga County Medical Examiner's Office began working with the DNA Doe Project to exhume unidentified victims for genetic genealogy analysis in an effort to determine their identities.
