Killing of Jack Dobbins (the "Candlestick murder")

Jack Dobbins was a 30-year-old chemical company executive employed by the Davidson Chemical Co. Division of W.R. Grace and Company. He was killed at his home on Queen Street in Charleston, South Carolina, in the early morning hours of November 1, 1958, following a Halloween party; his death is believed to have occurred between roughly 1:30 and 7:00 am. Dobbins had attended the party with his roommate, Edward Otey, a 25-year-old Medical University of South Carolina student, before leaving around 2:00 am. His body was discovered, unclothed, on his living room sofa by his maid, Elizabeth Bryant, who alerted Otey; Otey then called police. The Charleston News and Courier reported that Dobbins' head was bloodied from repeated blows near the left ear. An autopsy found he had been struck nine times, fracturing his skull in three places. Coroner Jennings Cauthren noted no signs of struggle, suggesting the attack was a surprise. A brass candlestick holder found in Dobbins' arms at the scene was believed to be the weapon, giving the case its name.

Edward Otey was initially considered a suspect but was later dismissed. John Mahon, an 18-year-old airman whom Dobbins had met that night at Club 49, a mixed gay and straight bar where Dobbins was helping to tend bar, became the primary suspect. After Dobbins served Mahon drinks, the two went to the Elbow Cocktail bar, where Mahon was refused entry for violating the dress code, and then returned to Dobbins' Queen Street home. Mahon later turned himself in to police and confessed to the killing, claiming self-defense. According to his account as reported by the Charleston News and Courier, Dobbins made "improper advances" toward him after serving him whisky; Mahon said he later found Dobbins unclothed in the living room and, after being told to "come here John," retrieved the candlestick from an upstairs bedroom and struck Dobbins.

Mahon was tried for murder beginning December 9, 1958. At trial, witnesses referenced Dobbins' sexuality, and the prosecution, led by Solicitor Theodore D. Stoney, argued a robbery motive, suggesting that "some people preyed on persons of abnormal behavior to get money." Mahon testified he struck Dobbins three or four times intending only to knock him out, then fled after tossing the candlestick onto the couch. The state sought the death penalty, but an all-male jury found Mahon not guilty on grounds of self-defense. He returned home to his family for Christmas.

The verdict, according to accounts cited in later analysis, deepened distrust of the justice system within Charleston's gay community; local resident Billy Camden described this reaction. Writer Thompson, identified as head of digital research services at University of Houston Libraries, characterized the trial's defense strategy and press coverage as reinforcing existing social hierarchies tied to sexuality and segregation in Charleston. Gay rights activist Leonard Matlovich later cited the case as a reminder of perceived consequences of homosexuality.