Unsolved case · 2009
Also known as Marsha Ellen Brantley · Marsha Rader
The short answer
Marsha Brantley, a Cleveland, Tennessee woman, disappeared around May to June 2009; her car, phone, and other valuables were left behind, and no direct evidence of what happened to her has ever been found. Her then-husband, Donnie Brantley, was charged with her murder in 2013 and again in 2016, but both charges were later dismissed for lack of evidence, and her disappearance remains unsolved.
1 piece from 1 creator: ranked, with duplicates removed and short clips set aside.
Marsha Brantley case: Evidence a jury never saw
48 HoursVideo · YouTube · 2 min · 2018Titles and descriptions are the creators’ own and may not reflect current legal status. The sourced facts are in the file below. Players load only when you press play. Suggest coverage we’re missing.
Marsha Ellen Brantley (née Rader) was born February 28, 1959, and was originally from Illinois. By the time of her disappearance she lived in Cleveland, Tennessee, where she had previously served as director of housing at Lee University. She was an amateur writer who was fond of her dogs and outdoor activities. Friends and family later told investigators that she suffered from depression. She married Donnie Brantley on March 28, 2000.
In 2008, friends began to suspect that the Brantleys' marriage was troubled, despite Marsha Brantley's own claims to the contrary. In March 2009, friends reported that she had told them she was "so depressed she couldn't get off the couch." Cell phone records later led investigators to conclude that she most likely disappeared on or around June 2, 2009, possibly as late as July, though earlier accounts had placed her disappearance more broadly between May and June of that year. In July or August 2009, a neighbor reported not having seen Brantley for a long time and said she appeared to have stopped her usual activities. Around the same time, Brantley's hairdresser asked Donnie Brantley where his wife was and was told that she had left him and that the couple was divorcing.
The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation opened an inquiry in 2009. Donnie Brantley told investigators that his wife had left voluntarily, but a search of the couple's home found her car, cell phone, clothing, and many other valuable belongings still inside. Local law enforcement came to consider it likely that Brantley had been murdered by her husband, though no direct evidence has ever been found to prove that a murder took place, and multiple investigations have failed to determine a cause for her disappearance. The Bradley County Sheriff's Office joined the investigation in 2011, and in November 2012 investigators searched the Brantleys' home again, this time using cadaver dogs.
In July 2013, a grand jury indicted Donnie Brantley on a charge of murdering his wife, and he was arrested and formally charged the following month. In May 2014, the charge was dismissed for lack of evidence. Brantley was arrested a second time in October 2016, in Kingston, Georgia, and was again charged with his wife's murder that December. Those charges were also dropped, in February 2018, again for lack of evidence.
On April 7, 2018, CBS's 48 Hours broadcast an episode on the case, titled "Missing Marsha," which raised the possibility of a financial motive. Marsha Brantley's disappearance remains unresolved, and no cause has ever been officially determined.
Marsha Rader married Donnie Brantley.
Friends began to suspect that the Brantleys' marriage was troubled, despite Marsha Brantley's own claims to the contrary.
Friends reported that Marsha Brantley told them she was "so depressed she couldn't get off the couch."
Cell phone records led investigators to conclude that Marsha Brantley most likely disappeared on or around this date, possibly as late as July; earlier accounts had placed her disappearance more broadly between May and June 2009.
In July or August, a neighbor reported not having seen Marsha Brantley for a long time and that she appeared to have stopped her usual activities; her hairdresser then asked Donnie Brantley about his wife's whereabouts and was told that she had left him and that the couple was divorcing.
The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation began investigating the case; Donnie Brantley told investigators his wife had left voluntarily, but a search of the home found her car, cell phone, clothing, and many other valuables left behind.
The Bradley County Sheriff's Office became involved in the investigation.
Investigators searched the Brantleys' home again, this time using cadaver dogs.
A grand jury indicted Donnie Brantley on a charge of murdering his wife.
Donnie Brantley was arrested and formally charged with murder.
The murder charge against Donnie Brantley was dismissed for lack of evidence.
Donnie Brantley was arrested a second time, in Kingston, Georgia.
Donnie Brantley was again charged with his wife's murder.
The murder charge against Donnie Brantley was dropped a second time, again for lack of evidence.
CBS's 48 Hours broadcast an episode on the case, titled "Missing Marsha," which raised the possibility of a financial motive.
Victims first. Every legal label is set from public records and court outcomes, not from the prose.
Disappeared from Cleveland, Tennessee, around May to June 2009, most likely on or around June 2, 2009 per cell phone records; her car, cell phone, clothing, and other valuables were left behind, and her fate has never been determined.[3]
Then-husband of Marsha Brantley, who disappeared in 2009 and whose body was never found. A grand jury indicted him in July 2013 and he was arrested and charged with her murder in August 2013; that charge was dismissed in May 2014 for lack of evidence. He was arrested and charged with her murder a second time in October/December 2016; those charges were dropped again in February 2018, also for lack of evidence. He has never been convicted or tried, and investigators' suspicion of him has never been established with direct evidence. No charges remain pending against him in this case (he has twice been charged and twice had the charges dropped, most recently in 2018).[3]
Coverage is not a source: every fact in this file rests on the records below.
Are you family of someone named in this file? Corrections and removal requests from victims’ families are prioritized.
Credit: VeggiesCC BY-SA 2.0SourceSOLVEDListenChattanooga, Tennessee, United States · 2010s
On July 16, 2015, Muhammad Youssef Abdulazeez opened fire at a military recruiting center and a Navy Reserve center in Chattanooga, Tennessee, killing four Marines and a Navy sailor before being fatally shot by police.
Credit: terrell, mary churchPublic domainSourceSOLVEDListenWalnut Street Bridge, Chattanooga, Tennessee · 1900s
On March 19, 1906, Ed Johnson, a young Black man convicted of raping Nevada Taylor in Chattanooga, Tennessee, was seized from jail by a mob and lynched from the Walnut Street Bridge, hours after the U.S. Supreme Court had issued a stay of execution. The lynching led to United States v. Shipp, the only criminal trial ever conducted by the Supreme Court, and Johnson's conviction was posthumously vacated in 2000.
UNSOLVEDListenWalnut Street Bridge, Chattanooga, Tennessee · 1900s
On February 9, 1893, Alfred Blount, an African American man from Chattanooga, Tennessee, was dragged from his county jail cell by a mob, beaten, stabbed, shot, and hanged from the Walnut Street Bridge after being accused of assaulting a woman, with no sufficient evidence later found to support the charge.
Credit: FBIPublic domainSourceONGOINGListenOrlando, Florida, United States · 2006
Jennifer Joyce Kesse, a 24-year-old finance manager, disappeared from her home in Orlando, Florida, between January 23 and 24, 2006; her car was found abandoned about a mile away two days later, and she has never been found.
Credit: AuburnPilot at English WikipediaPublic domainSourceUNSOLVEDListenOranjestad, Aruba · 2005
Natalee Holloway, an 18-year-old Alabama high school graduate, disappeared during a graduation trip to Aruba on May 30, 2005, and has never been found; Joran van der Sloot, last seen with her that night, was never charged over her disappearance in Aruba but later pleaded guilty to related U.S. extortion and wire-fraud charges and confessed to killing her.
Credit: Federal Bureau of InvestigationPublic domainSourceUNSOLVEDListenWashington, D.C. · 2014
An 8-year-old girl living at a Washington, D.C., homeless shelter disappeared in early 2014 while in the custody of a shelter janitor who had befriended her family; she has never been found.
