Before you continue
This case involves sexual violence. Casepin presents the record in neutral, non-graphic language. Choose whether to continue.
Solved case · 1936
Also known as Beekman Place Bathtub Murder · Nancy Evans Titterton
Midtown Manhattan October 2022 073Credit: Kidfly182·CC BY-SA 4.0·Source
The short answer
Nancy Titterton, an aspiring novelist and wife of an NBC executive, was raped and strangled in her Manhattan apartment in April 1936; forensic tracing of a horsehair fiber led to the conviction and execution of John Fiorenza.
The coverage index
No one's coverage is attached to this file yet.
Know great coverage of this case?
A documentary, a podcast episode, a careful long-form video. Suggest it and an editor will review it before it appears here.
Suggest coverage for Murder of Nancy TittertonThe case file
Nancy Violet Evans Titterton was born in Ohio in 1903 and moved to New York, where she worked for the New York Post in the late 1920s. There she met Englishman Lewis Henry Titterton, whom she married in 1929. Her husband rose to become an executive at the National Broadcasting Company, and the couple lived in an apartment near the East River in Manhattan. Nancy pursued a writing career; her work "I Shall Decline My Head" appeared on the cover of the August 1935 issue of Story Magazine, and in 1935 she received a book deal following publication of a short story. By 1936 she was preparing to write her first novel.
On the morning of April 10, 1936, 34-year-old Nancy Titterton was killed inside her apartment at 22 Beekman Place. Her body was discovered that afternoon by Theodore Kruger and John Fiorenza, two furniture repairmen delivering a couch that had been reupholstered. She was found in a bathtub, having been raped and strangled to death.
The crime scene yielded little physical evidence beyond a 13-inch piece of cord and a single hair recovered from the bed. Investigators initially dismissed the hair as belonging to the victim, but further examination revealed it was horsehair, a material used as stuffing in upholstery. The case, quickly dubbed by the press as the Beekman Place "Bathtub Murder," attracted extensive media coverage.
The case was solved when Alexander Gettler, a scientist at the Office of Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York, traced the horsehair to a local upholstery shop that had recently serviced furniture in the Titterton apartment. That shop was owned by Theodore Kruger, one of the men who had discovered the body, with John Fiorenza working there as an assistant. The horsehair evidence led police to focus suspicion on Fiorenza, an ex-convict, who subsequently confessed to the crime.
Fiorenza stood trial for the murder, which concluded on May 28, 1936, after a jury deliberated for 19 hours before returning a guilty verdict. He was sentenced to death and held at Sing Sing prison. Fiorenza was executed in the electric chair on January 22, 1937.
The case is noted as an early instance of a homicide solved through forensic trace-evidence analysis, specifically the microscopic identification and sourcing of a single hair fiber.
6 dated entries · 1903–1937
Nancy Violet Evans is born in Ohio.
Nancy Evans marries Lewis Henry Titterton.
Her work "I Shall Decline My Head" is featured on the cover of Story Magazine.
Nancy Titterton is found dead, raped and strangled, in the bathtub of her apartment at 22 Beekman Place, Manhattan; discovered by furniture repairmen Theodore Kruger and John Fiorenza.
John Fiorenza's murder trial concludes with a guilty verdict after a 19-hour jury deliberation; he is sentenced to death.
John Fiorenza is executed by electric chair at Sing Sing prison.
2 named in this file
Victims first. Every legal label is set from public records and court outcomes, not from the prose.
From the record
3 cited
Coverage is not a source: every fact in this file rests on the records below.
PressThe New York TimesAccessed Jul 7, 2026
PressBBC NewsAccessed Jul 7, 2026
EncyclopedicWikipediaAccessed Jul 7, 2026
Trust
Are you family of someone named in this file? Corrections and removal requests from victims’ families are prioritized.
Near this case
SOLVEDListen313 East 51st Street, Turtle Bay-Beekman Place, New York City · 1940s
Patricia Lonergan, heiress to the Lion Brewery fortune, was beaten and strangled in her New York City apartment in October 1943. Her estranged husband, Royal Canadian Air Force pilot Wayne Lonergan, was arrested in Toronto, extradited, and convicted of second-degree murder in a highly publicized 1944 trial.
Image record·Public domain·SourceSOLVEDListenNew York Marriott East Side hotel, 525 Lexington Avenue, Manhattan · 1990s
On 5 November 1990, Israeli-American rabbi and politician Meir Kahane was shot and killed while speaking at a Manhattan hotel; El Sayyid Nosair was charged with the murder but was convicted only of related assault and weapons offenses, not the killing itself.
Credit: no human authorship, CCTV at HI New York City Hostel·Public domain·SourceONGOINGListenOutside the New York Hilton Midtown, West 54th Street, Manhattan · 2020s
Brian Thompson, CEO of UnitedHealthcare, was shot and killed outside the New York Hilton Midtown on December 4, 2024. Luigi Mangione was arrested days later in Pennsylvania and charged in New York and federal court with murder, terrorism-related offenses, and weapons charges; he has pleaded not guilty.
Credit: Wikipedia/Wikimedia Commons infobox portrait·Public domain·SourceSOLVEDListenSanta Beatriz Hippodrome (now Campo de Marte), Santa Beatriz, Lima, Peru · 1933
On April 30, 1933, Peruvian President Luis Miguel Sánchez Cerro was fatally shot from behind while riding in his open-topped car at the Santa Beatriz Hippodrome in Lima. The gunman, APRA militant Abelardo Mendoza Leyva, was killed at the scene by presidential guards; a Republican Guard member was also killed in the attack.
Credit: Harris & Ewing, photographer·Public domain·SourceCOLDListenLouisiana State Capitol, Baton Rouge, Louisiana · 1935
On September 8, 1935, U.S. Senator and former Louisiana Governor Huey Long was shot at the Louisiana State Capitol in Baton Rouge and died 31 hours later. Carl Weiss, son-in-law of a judge Long had just moved to remove from office, was killed at the scene by Long's bodyguards; the exact circumstances of Long's fatal wound remain disputed.
Credit: Unknown author Unknown author·Public domain·SourceCOLDListenBrighton, England · 1930
In 1934, two separate murders in Brighton, England involved women's bodies being found in trunks. The first victim remains unidentified and her killer was never found. The second victim, Violette Kaye, was found in her partner Toni Mancini's lodgings; Mancini was tried for her murder and acquitted, but confessed to killing her decades later, shortly before his death.
