Unsolved case · 1857
The short answer
In 1857, five California-bound travelers were seized in central Utah on unsubstantiated spying accusations and killed, allegedly on the orders of senior leaders of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
No one's coverage is attached to this file yet.
Know great coverage of this case?
A documentary, a podcast episode, a careful long-form video. Suggest it and an editor will review it before it appears here.
Suggest coverage for Aiken massacreThe Aiken massacre refers to the 1857 killing of five travelers from California in central Utah. The victims were reportedly apprehended on trumped-up charges of spying, imprisoned, and then murdered. Two of the men initially escaped the killings with injuries but were tracked down and killed two days later. The event took place approximately two months after the Mountain Meadows Massacre and is described as part of the impetus for the Utah War (1857–1858).
The name of the massacre derives from brothers Thomas and John Aiken, two members of the traveling party who were among those killed.
The killings were reportedly carried out at the orders of top leaders within The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the largest denomination of Mormonism. In 1877, two decades after the killings, Porter Rockwell and Wild Bill Hickman were indicted in connection with the massacre. Hickman, who by that time had been excommunicated from the church, gave a confession stating that after one victim identified as Bucklin ("Buck") escaped an initial murder attempt, territorial governor and top church president Brigham Young ordered him to finish the job.
Historian John G. Turner has stated that it is likely Young was involved in the deaths of four members of the party, as well as in the death of a trader named Richard Yates approximately a month prior to the massacre.
The Aiken massacre occurred in the broader context of tensions in the Utah Territory during 1857, closely following the Mountain Meadows Massacre. It has been cited as a contributing factor to the outbreak of the Utah War between the United States government and Mormon settlers in the Utah Territory, which unfolded from 1857 to 1858.
No conviction, acquittal, or other disposition is recorded for either man's 1877 indictment.
Five travelers from California, including brothers Thomas and John Aiken, are apprehended in central Utah on accusations of spying, imprisoned, and killed; two who initially escaped with injuries were killed two days later.
Porter Rockwell and Wild Bill Hickman are indicted for the massacre; Hickman, by then excommunicated from the LDS Church, gives a confession implicating Brigham Young in ordering the killing of an escaped victim identified as Bucklin ("Buck").
Victims first. Every legal label is set from public records and court outcomes, not from the prose.
Referred to as "Buck"; initially escaped a murder attempt but was reportedly ordered killed afterward per Wild Bill Hickman's confession.[3]
One of two Aiken brothers killed in the massacre; the massacre is named after the Aiken brothers.[3]
One of two Aiken brothers killed in the massacre; the massacre is named after the Aiken brothers.[3]
Indicted in 1877 in connection with the Aiken massacre.[3]
Indicted in 1877 in connection with the Aiken massacre; later excommunicated from the LDS Church and gave a confession describing his role and implicating Brigham Young.[3]
Coverage is not a source: every fact in this file rests on the records below.
Are you family of someone named in this file? Corrections and removal requests from victims’ families are prioritized.
UNSOLVEDListenYuba Lake campground, Juab County, Utah · 1970s
Marilee Lee Bruszer disappeared from Long Beach, California, in August 1978 and was found strangled near Yuba Lake, Utah, days later, but was not identified until 2015 due to inaccurate physical estimates and the long distance between disappearance and discovery sites.
Credit: JacobkhedPublic domainSourceUNSOLVEDListenSalt Creek Canyon, near Nephi, Juab County, Utah · 1850s
On June 4, 1858, four Danish immigrants traveling to a Mormon settlement in Sanpete Valley, Utah, were ambushed and killed by unidentified Indigenous attackers in Salt Creek Canyon; a fifth member of the group escaped.
Camp Salina, Salina, Utah, United States · 1940s
At midnight on July 8, 1945, American guard Clarence V. Bertucci opened machine-gun fire on sleeping German prisoners of war at Camp Salina, Utah, killing nine and wounding nineteen.
Credit: Unknown authorPublic domainSourceSOLVEDListenHarpers Ferry, Virginia (now West Virginia) · 1859
From October 16–18, 1859, abolitionist John Brown led a group of 22 men in an attempt to seize the federal armory at Harpers Ferry, Virginia, hoping to spark a slave uprising. The raid failed after a standoff and an assault by U.S. Marines under Robert E. Lee; ten raiders were killed, seven were later tried and executed, and five escaped.
SOLVEDListenJacksonville, Oregon (then Rogue River area, Oregon Territory) · 1852
In May 1852, Robert S. Maynard, a 21-year-old gambler from Illinois, shot and killed J. C. Platt in the Rogue River mining area of what would become Jacksonville, Oregon, after a verbal insult; miners then extrajudicially hanged Maynard in what is recorded as the first lynching in Southern Oregon.
SOLVEDListenLouisville School, Louisville, Kentucky · 1853
In 1853 Louisville, Kentucky, 15-year-old student William Ward's older brother Matthews Ward shot schoolteacher William Butler after a dispute over classroom discipline; Butler died the next day and Matthews Ward was acquitted at trial in 1854.
