Solved case · 1890
The short answer
Eli Ladd, a Black barber and farmer, was chased and fatally shot more than fifty times by a group of white men in Blountsville, Indiana, on February 7, 1890. Five men were arrested; three were convicted of manslaughter and served two-year prison sentences.
No one's coverage is attached to this file yet.
Know great coverage of this case?
A documentary, a podcast episode, a careful long-form video. Suggest it and an editor will review it before it appears here.
Suggest coverage for Lynching of Eli LaddReuben Eli Ladd was born in 1869 and grew up near Mooreland, in Henry County, Indiana. His parents were Isaac and Sarah Ladd (née Means), and he lived with them and his younger sister, Julia, on the farm of his maternal grandparents, Reuben and Leah Means, in Blue River Township. The Means family had lived in the area since at least 1840. Ladd worked on the family farm from a young age and was also employed as a barber, and some contemporary newspapers referred to him as the "Mooreland barber."
On February 7, 1890, in Blountsville, Indiana, Ladd was chased and shot by a small group of white men who fired more than fifty rounds at him. The Muncie Morning News reported on February 8, 1890, that Ladd had been shot six times. Ladd was lynched after confronting a vigilante group of white men who accused him of assaulting a white woman. The lynching has been described as part of a broader pattern in which white mobs in Indiana used violence to enforce Jim Crow-era racial control during the Reconstruction period. Men frequently cited as leaders of the mob include William Rozell (also spelled Razell), Cassius (sometimes Charles) Lake, Charles Smelzer, John Davis, and J.P. Smith. Some accounts suggest there may have been an ongoing "private feud" between Ladd and one of these men.
On February 10, 1890, arrest warrants were issued for William Rozell, Cassius Lake, Charles Smeltzer, and J.P. Smith, who were taken to the Henry County jail to await trial. On February 15, 1890, the Muncie Morning News reported that attorney Rollin Warner had been engaged to defend the accused men. On May 22, 1890, a jury acquitted Cassius Lake. On June 23, 1890, the "Smeltzer-Ladd" murder trial began before Judge Lotz in Delaware County Court. The Muncie Morning News reported on July 7, 1890, that Smeltzer had been convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to two years in the Indiana State Prison.
A separate trial for William Rozell began on December 29, 1890, at the New Castle Circuit Court. On January 11, 1891, John P. Smith testified that Rozell had conspired to murder Ladd the night before the lynching. Rozell was subsequently convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to two years in prison. Smith pleaded guilty to manslaughter and also received a two-year sentence.
The case drew regional attention; the Wheeling Register, a West Virginia newspaper, reportedly commented critically on what it characterized as "Hoosier hypocrisy," noting that the lynching had occurred in a county that voted Republican.
Reuben Eli Ladd born near Mooreland, Henry County, Indiana.
Eli Ladd is chased and fatally shot by a group of white men in Blountsville, Indiana.
The Muncie Morning News reports Ladd had been shot six times.
Arrest warrants issued for the Rozell brothers, Cassius Lake, Charles Smeltzer, and J.P. Smith; suspects taken to Henry County jail.
Muncie Morning News reports attorney Rollin Warner engaged to defend the accused men.
Jury acquits Cassius Lake.
Smeltzer-Ladd murder trial begins under Judge Lotz in Delaware County Court.
Muncie Morning News reports Smeltzer convicted of manslaughter, sentenced to two years in Indiana State Prison.
Trial of William Rozell begins at New Castle Circuit Court.
John P. Smith testifies that William Rozell conspired to murder Ladd the night before the lynching; Rozell later convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to two years in prison; Smith pleads guilty to manslaughter, receiving the same sentence.
Victims first. Every legal label is set from public records and court outcomes, not from the prose.
Black barber and farmer chased and fatally shot by a mob in Blountsville, Indiana, on February 7, 1890.[3]
Convicted of manslaughter for killing Eli Ladd; sentenced to two years in the Indiana State Prison.[3]
Pleaded guilty to manslaughter in connection with Ladd's killing; sentenced to two years in prison.[3]
Convicted of manslaughter in connection with Ladd's killing; sentenced to two years in prison.[3]
Arrested in connection with Ladd's killing; acquitted by a jury on May 22, 1890.[3]
From the record
Coverage is not a source: every fact in this file rests on the records below.
Are you family of someone named in this file? Corrections and removal requests from victims’ families are prioritized.
SOLVEDListenDeer Lick Creek encampment near Fall Creek, Madison County, Indiana · 1820s
On March 22, 1824, seven white settlers killed nine Native Americans camped along Deer Lick Creek near present-day Pendleton, Indiana; four of the men were later convicted and sentenced to death, in what is recorded as the first case under U.S. law in which white men were executed for killing Native Americans.
COLDListenRichmond, Indiana, United States · 2000s
Marilyn “Niqui” McCown disappeared from Richmond, Indiana, in July 2001, and police continue to investigate without an arrest or charge.
UNSOLVEDListenHancock County Fairgrounds, Greenfield, Indiana · 1870s
William Keemer, a Black carpenter, was dragged from the Hancock County Jail in Greenfield, Indiana, by a white mob of 150–160 men on June 25, 1875, and hanged at the county fairgrounds after being accused, but never tried, for an alleged sexual assault.
Credit: Photographer not creditedPublic domainSourceUNSOLVEDListenParish Prison, New Orleans, Louisiana · 1891
On March 14, 1891, a mob in New Orleans broke into Parish Prison and killed eleven Italian American men held in connection with the October 1890 killing of police chief David Hennessy, a day after several of the defendants were acquitted at trial. It remains the largest single mass lynching in American history.
Credit: Unknown staff member at the New York HeraldPublic domainSourceSOLVEDListenNear Maud, Oklahoma Territory · 1898
In January 1898, a white mob near Maud, Oklahoma Territory, burned two Seminole teenagers, Lincoln McGeisey and Palmer Sampson, alive after accusing them without evidence of the murder of Mary Leard. Federal prosecution later led to six convictions, the first successful lynching prosecution in the Southwestern United States.
UNSOLVEDListenLake City, South Carolina, United States · 1898
Frazier B. Baker, the Black postmaster of Lake City, South Carolina, and his infant daughter Julia were killed on February 22, 1898, when a white mob set fire to their home and shot at the family as they fled. A federal trial ended in a mistrial after a deadlocked jury, and no one was ever convicted.
